B. Millat et al., LAPAROSCOPIC TREATMENT FOR CHOLEDOCHOLITHIASIS - A PROSPECTIVE EVALUATION IN 247 CONSECUTIVE UNSELECTED PATIENTS, Hepato-gastroenterology, 44(13), 1997, pp. 28-34
Background/Aims: Evaluation of the feasibility and results of the one-
stage treatment combining routine intraoperative cholangiography and l
aparoscopic common. bile duct exploration for choledocholithiasis. Pat
ients and Methods: Multicentric (5 centers-9 surgeons) prospective stu
dy in 247 consecutive patients (mean age 68 years; range 21-92) during
a 50-month period (November 1991-December 1995). Laparoscopic treatme
nt of choledocholithiasis teas attempted irrespective of the circumsta
nces leading to the diagnosis of biliary lithiasis or the preoperative
suspicion. of choledocholithiasis. Results: One out of four patients
(n=61) had unsuspected choledocholithiasis disclosed by routine intrao
perative cholangiography. A laparoscopic complete clearance of choledo
cholithiasis was achieved in 208 of 236 attempted cases (88%), with ei
ther transcystic duct extraction (n=116) or choledochotomy (n=92). Ope
n, surgery was required in 20 patients for failure of Laparoscopic tre
atment and in 3 patients despite successful extraction. Twenty-one of
25 patients (84%) referred for failure of retrograde endoscopic stone
extraction had successful laparoscopic choledocholithiasis clearance.
The mean duration for the laparoscopic transcystic approach and choled
ochotomy were 108 min. (range 50-300) and 173 min. (range 70-480), res
pectively. Eleven patients had retained stones (4.4%). Minor and major
complications were recorded in 9 and 22 patients respectively. The op
erative mortality was 0.4% (95% confidence interval: 0-1.2%). Conclusi
on: Intraoperative cholangiography during laparoscopic cholecystectomy
and Laparoscopic common bile duct exploration when required should be
considered as the simplest and most efficient treatment for choledoch
olithiasis. The multicenter character of this study including consecut
ive patients from public and private practices, strengthens our conclu
sions and is consistent with a wide diffusion, of this diagnostic and
therapeutic strategy.