M. Levy et al., UNFAVORABLE OUTCOMES (END-STAGE RENAL FAILURE DEATH) IN CHILDHOOD-ONSET SYSTEMIC LUPUS-ERYTHEMATOSUS - A MULTICENTER STUDY IN PARIS AND ITSENVIRONS/, Clinical and experimental rheumatology, 12, 1994, pp. 190000063-190000068
Thirty of 118 cases of childhood onset systemic lupus erythematosus co
llected in the Parisian area had an unfavorable outcome. Thirteen pati
ents evolved to end-stage renal failure. Seven survived with renal sub
stitution therapy, and 6 other patients subsequently died Most had dif
fuse proliferative glomerulonephritis, the pattern of glomerular disea
se classically responsible for end-stage renal failure. Three patients
had membranous nephropathy with segmental lesions, a form of glomerul
onephritis whose severe prognosis should be emphasized. In another pat
ient, end-stage renal failure was precipitated by thrombotic microangi
opathy. Seventeen other patients died and in most, the causes of death
were multiple. In 7, death could be attributed to complications secon
dary to an infection and in 4 other cases to SLE exacerbation with sev
ere organ involvement. Two patients died suddenly, another showed card
iac failure and another had malignant hypertension. Of the remaining 2
patients, one suffered anticoagulant therapy complications after trea
tment for renal artery stenosis and the second, an urothelial carcinom
a. Unfavorable evolutions were high among patients coming from French
departments and territories, and among North African patients. One may
speculate that poor outcome is associated with ethnic characteristics
or with socioeconomic factors. However, the problem of compliance wit
h treatment is clearly an extremely important factor in the prognosis.
Both end-stage renal failure and death were in some of our cases prec
ipitated by treatment interruption, indicating an insufficient underst
anding of the importance of treatment in this chronic disease.