The mortality of critically ill patients with acute renal failure has
been halved through intervention by haemodialysis. However, several re
ports suggest that the course df the disorder may be prolonged by this
procedure. Our prospective randomised study was done to see whether t
he generation of inflammatory mediators by bio-incompatible membranes
has an adverse effect on the outcome of acute renal failure. 52 patien
ts, similar in age, severity of acute renal failure, general disease s
tatus (APACHE II),and management of acute renal failure or its related
conditions, were divided into two groups. Haemodialysis was done with
cuprophane or polyacrylonitrile membranes. Cuprophane membranes induc
ed intense activation of the complement system (as judged by measureme
nt of C3a) and lipooxygenase pathway (leukotriene 84) resulting in alt
erations of neutrophil kinetics and function. The cuprophane group had
a lower survival rate (38 vs 65%), a higher proportion of patients dy
ing from sepsis (71 vs 40%), required more haemodialysis sessions (12
vs 9), and demonstrated delayed resolution and recovery from acute ren
al failure than the polyacrylonitrile group. The difference in mortali
ty regarding lethal sepsis as cause of death was statistically signifi
cant. Our observations indicate that the outcome of critically ill pat
ients with acute renal failure may be influenced by bio-incompatibilit
y reactions to the dialysis membrane. These results have direct implic
ations for such patients on haemodialysis.