Simulated annealing and taboo search are well-established local search
methods for obtaining approximate solutions to a variety of combinato
rial optimization problems. More recently, genetic algorithms have als
o been applied. However, there are few studies which compare the relat
ive performance of these different methods on the same problem. In thi
s paper, these techniques are applied to the problem of scheduling job
s on unrelated parallel machines to minimize the maximum completion ti
me. Results of extensive computational tests indicate that the quality
of solutions generated by a genetic algorithm is poor. However, a hyb
rid method in which descent is incorporated into the genetic algorithm
is comparable in performance with simulated annealing and taboo searc
h.