Two coercivity models, a phenomenological model developed by Givord el
al. and a micromagnetic model developed by Kronmuller et al., have be
en used to analyze the temperature dependence of the coercive field of
sintered Pr17Fe75B8 and Pr17Fe53B30 permanent magnets. A general comp
arison of these two models is made. The micromagnetic model takes into
account the misalignment of grains and the anisotropy imperfections a
t the grain surface. From the analysis based on this model it follows
that the coercivity in sintered Pr17Fe75B8 and Pr17Fe53B30 permanent m
agnets is controlled by a nucleation mechanism occurring preferentiall
y in the grain surface where the magnetic anisotropy is reduced and th
e local demagnetizing field is the highest. A simple proportional rela
tionship between the micromagnetic parameters and N(eff) is found. In
addition, the effect of magnetic coupling among grains can be estimate
d with this model. The phenomenological model takes into account the g
eometrical effect of nucleated domains, the effect of the disturbance
of domain-wall energy, and the thermal activation. From the analysis b
ased on this model, it follows that the expansion of reversed domains
takes place preferentially in regions where the domain-wall energy is
reduced and where a spikelike reversed domain is energetically favorab
le. It is demonstrated in the present investigation that the phenomeno
logical model corresponds approximately to the micromagnetic model whe
n the nucleation process dominates the magnetization reversal process
and the magnetic coupling between grains is weak.