This study compared the cephalometric changes achieved using fixed ver
sus removable appliances to correct deep overbite in growing patients.
Forty-five patients treated with cervical headgear/tandem mechanics a
nd 50 patients treated with a bionator appliance were compared with 95
control subjects from the Bolton Study. Treatment differences were de
termined using a cephalometric analysis that isolated vertical changes
in overbite as the composite result of 6 variables: maxillary skeleta
l change, tipping of the upper incisors, bodily movement of the upper
incisors, mandibular skeletal change, lower incisor tipping, and bodil
y movement of the lower incisors. The interaction of treatment type wi
th facial type was also examined. In the headgear/tandem group, overbi
te was corrected by a combination of intrusion of the upper incisors a
nd increases in mandibular skeletal change. Treatment with the bionato
r resulted in correction of the overbite by relative intrusion of the
upper and lower incisors and increases in mandibular skeletal change.
There were no significant interactions with facial type in the headgea
r group. Gonial angle and lower tipping were influenced by facial type
in the bionator group. These results demonstrate that fixed and remov
able appliances produce both qualitative and quantitative differences
in treatment response. Further studies are planned to create a rationa
l decision tree that can be used to aid the clinician in the different
ial diagnosis and treatment of deep overbite.