Wx. Yao et al., MOTOR SKILL ACQUISITION AND RETENTION AS A FUNCTION OF AVERAGE FEEDBACK, SUMMARY FEEDBACK, AND PERFORMANCE VARIABILITY, Journal of motor behavior, 26(3), 1994, pp. 273-282
Summary feedback involves withholding feedback from subjects until the
last trial in a block is completed, and then presenting feedback abou
t each trial. A variation of this method, called average feedback (You
ng & Schmidt, 1992), presents subjects with only the mean of the trial
block. We investigated whether these methods have similar effects on
acquisition and retention of a simple motor skill. Five groups of subj
ects (n = 16 per group) performed 60 acquisition trials of an aiming t
ask involving both spatial and temporal accuracy. We presented average
and summary feedback based on either 5-trial blocks or 15-trial block
s and compared these schedules with every-trial feedback. During acqui
sition, all groups improved with practice, with a slight tendency for
the every-trial condition to have less absolute error than the longer
summary and average conditions. Analysis of delayed no-feedback retent
ion tests, however, revealed a strong advantage for the 5-trial summar
y and average conditions compared with the every-trial condition. In a
ddition, we found that for long blocks of acquisition trials without a
ugmented feedback, the performance variability of those trials was ass
ociated with retention performance. Results are discussed in terms of
how these different manipulations may make feedback less useful during
acquisition, but foster the use of certain information processing act
ivities that enhance overall learning.