An unrecognized problem is examined in a frequently used method for de
composing earnings functions in the measurement of discrimination. The
conventional method decomposes changes in the log of the geometric me
an of the distribution, as opposed to the correct quantity, which is t
he change in the log of the arithmetic mean. Using the log of the geom
etric mean involves decomposing both changes in the mean and the sprea
d of the distribution. But the mean and the spread of many earnings fu
nctions are subject to change, so it is not quite clear what this deco
mposition achieves. Two examples illustrate timewise and cross-section
al comparisons.