Ch. Lu et Rw. Proctor, PROCESSING OF AN IRRELEVANT LOCATION DIMENSION AS A FUNCTION OF THE RELEVANT STIMULUS DIMENSION, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance, 20(2), 1994, pp. 286-298
The effect of an irrelevant location dimension on choice reactions to
the relevant stimulus dimension was examined. Experiment 1 used variat
ions of the spatial Stroop task and the Simon task that differed in wh
ether the relevant dimension (location name or color) was similar to t
he irrelevant location dimension. Congruity of the stimulus dimensions
and stimulus-response (S-R) mapping had additive effects in the Simon
task but overadditive effects in the Stroop task. Experiments 2-4 sho
wed that each pattern could be obtained for both tasks, suggesting tha
t dimensional similarity is not crucial; overadditivity occurred only
when stimulus identification was prolonged. The results can be interpr
eted in terms of the relative timing of activation for the relevant an
d irrelevant information, if it is assumed that the activation functio
n for irrelevant location varies across different stimulus-response ma
ppings.