We calculate the energies of different solid phases of Al2O3 using a s
hell model, a compressible ion model, and a compressible ion model whi
ch includes both dipole and quadrupolar polarizability of the O2- ions
. Compressible oxygen ions are found to stabilize the corundum structu
re with respect to the a form of alumina. The observed corundum struct
ure is nevertheless unstable with respect to the bixbyite structure Un
til quadripolar polarizability of the oxygen is also included. Entropy
differences are estimated with a lattice dynamics calculation and are
found to make an insignificant contribution to stabilizing the corund
um. We also calculate the relative energies of the corundum and bixbyi
te structures using the ab initio pseudopotential method, within the l
ocal-density approximation for exchange and correlation. The resulting
self-consistent electron density shows graphically how the quadrupola
r distortions around the oxygen develop as the basis is made more comp
lete (the plane-wave cutoff is increased from 500 to 700 eV), which at
the same time brings the energy of the corundum structure below that
of the bixbyite structure.