M. Aberhan et Ft. Fursich, DIVERSITY ANALYSIS OF LOWER JURASSIC BIVALVES OF THE ANDEAN BASIN ANDTHE PLIENSBACHIAN-TOARCIAN MASS EXTINCTION, Lethaia, 29(2), 1996, pp. 181-195
In the Andean Basin of southern South America marine bivalves show a m
arked decrease in diversity across the Pliensbachian-Toarcian boundary
. This observation is in contrast to earlier statements, according to
which a drop in diversity of marine organisms at the boundary is restr
icted to epicontinental seas of Western Europe. The decrease in bivalv
e diversity within the Andean Basin is largely due to the extinction o
f endemics and of some cosmopolitan species, less commonly to the Laza
rus effect and local disappearances of taxa. As the only two regions f
or which detailed data are available (Andean Basin and Western Europe)
exhibit similar diversity patterns across the boundary, the extinctio
n event is not a regional feature, but appears to be global. In both r
egions the mass extinction correlates with sea-level highstand and wid
espread oxygen-poor deep-shelf environments suggesting a causative rel
ationship. As shallow, largely well-aerated shelf environments in the
Andean Basin also exhibit, though less markedly, a drop in bivalve div
ersity across the boundary, oxygen deficiency cannot be the sole cause
of the mass extinction. Rather, in our model we assume sea-level chan
ges and the resulting oceanographic and biotic changes to be the ultim
ately controlling factors of species diversity patterns. The apparent
global character of the Pliensbachian-Toarcian mass extinction fits th
e periodicity hypothesis. However, as the mass extinction does not app
ear to have been catastrophic and as there is no indication of impact(
s) of extraterrestrial bodies, the oceanographic model proposed here i
s regarded as a more plausible (because it is more parsimonious) hypot
hesis.