Cw. Hoge et al., AN EPIDEMIC OF PNEUMOCOCCAL DISEASE IN AN OVERCROWDED, INADEQUATELY VENTILATED JAIL, The New England journal of medicine, 331(10), 1994, pp. 643-648
Background. In the United States many correctional facilities now oper
ate at far over capacity, with the potential for living conditions tha
t permit outbreaks of respiratory infections. We investigated an outbr
eak that was identified in an overcrowded Houston jail after two inmat
es died of pneumococcal sepsis on the same day. Outbreaks of pneumococ
cal disease have been rare in the era of antibiotics. Methods. We asse
ssed risk factors for pneumococcal disease in both a case-control and
a cohort study. Ventilation was evaluated by measuring carbon dioxide
levels and air flow to the living areas of the jail. The extent of asy
mptomatic infection was determined by culturing pharyngeal specimens f
rom a random sample of inmates. Type-specific immunity was determined
with an enzyme immunoassay. Results. Over a four-week period, 46 inmat
es had either acute pneumonia or invasive pneumococcal disease due to
Streptococcus pneumoniae serotype 12F. The jail's capacity had been se
t at 3500 inmates, but it housed 6700 at the time of the outbreak; the
inmates had a median living area of only 34 ft(2) (3.2 m(2)) (interqu
artile range, 28 to 56 ft(2) [2.6 to 5.2 m(2)]) per person. There were
significantly fewer cases of disease among inmates with 80 ft(2) (7.4
m(2)) per person or more (P = 0.030). Carbon dioxide levels ranged fr
om 1100 to 2500 ppm (acceptable, <1000), and the ventilation system de
livered a median of only 6.1 ft(3) of outside air per minute per perso
n (interquartile range, 4.4 to 8.5 ft(3); recommended, greater than or
equal to 20 ft(3)). The attack rate was highest among inmates in cell
s with the highest carbon dioxide levels and the lowest volume of outs
ide air delivered by the ventilation system (relative risk, 1.94; 95 p
ercent confidence interval, 1.08 to 3.48). Of underlying medical condi
tions, intravenous drug use was most strongly associated with disease
(odds ratio, 4.50). The epidemic strain (serotype 12F) was cultured fr
om 7 percent of the asymptomatic inmates. Of 11 case patients tested w
ith the enzyme immunoassay, 9 (82 percent) lacked preexisting immunity
to this strain. Conclusions. Severe overcrowding, inadequate ventilat
ion, and altered host susceptibility all contributed to this outbreak
of pneumococcal disease in a large urban jail.