One of the very valuable features of Ecological Economics is its provi
sion for publications under the rubric 'Commentary'. In that way, essa
ys which are not research in the strictest sense can still find proper
refereed publication, and can be submitted to the further test of ope
n colleague criticism. This paper is intended to be read in that spiri
t; and where criticisms are made of the work of particular scholars, t
hat is done because of the significance of their contribution.