Ca. Davis et Ml. Weisman, BALANCED DYNAMICS OF MESOSCALE VORTICES PRODUCED IN SIMULATED CONVECTIVE SYSTEMS, Journal of the atmospheric sciences, 51(14), 1994, pp. 2005-2030
Long-lived, mesoscale convective systems are known to occasionally pro
duce mesoscale convective vortices (MCVs) in the lower to middle tropo
sphere with horizontal scales averaging 100-200 km. The formation of M
CVs is investigated using fully three-dimensional cloud model simulati
ons of idealized, mesoscale convective systems (MCSs), initialized wit
h a finite length line of unstable perturbations. In agreement with ob
servations, the authors find that environmental conditions favoring MC
V formation exhibit weak vertical shear confined to roughly the lowest
3 km, provided the Coriolis parameter (f) is chosen appropriate for m
idlatitudes. With f = 0, counterrotating vortices form on the line end
s, positive to the north and negative to the south with westerly envir
onmental shear. The MCV and end vortices are synonymous with anomalies
of potential vorticity (PV). Using PV inversion techniques, the autho
rs show that the vortices are nearly balanced, even with f = 0. Howeve
r, the formation of mesoscale vortices depends upon the unbalanced, sl
oping, front-to-rear and rear inflow circulations of the mature squall
line. End vortices form partly from the tilting of ambient shear but
more from the tilting of the perturbation horizontal vorticity inheren
t in the squall line circulation. With the addition of earth's rotatio
n, an asymmetric structure results with the cyclonic vortex dominant o
n the northern end of the line. The key to this MCV formation is organ
ized convergence above the surface cold pool and associated mesoscale
ascent and latent heating. A simulated MCV can even form in an environ
ment with no ambient shear. Using a balanced model, the authors perfor
m extended time integrations and show that the MCV produced in a shear
ed environment remains largely intact because the shear is confined to
low levels and is relatively weak. In addition, the interaction of th
e vortex with the shear produces sufficient, mesoscale vertical motion
on the downshear side of the vortex to trigger convection in typical,
observed thermodynamic environments. Results suggest that balanced dy
namical arguments may elucidate the long-term behavior of mesoscale vo
rtices. However, because the balance equations neglect the irrotationa
l velocity contribution to the horizontal vorticity, the formation of
the mesoscale updraft that leads to an MCV and the generation of verti
cal vorticity through vortex tilting are both treated improperly. Thus
, the authors believe that existing balanced models will have serious
difficulty simulating MCS evolution and mesoscale vortex formation unl
ess mesoscale environmental forcing determines the behavior of the con
vective system.