Em. Scarpelli et Aj. Mautone, SURFACE BIOPHYSICS OF THE SURFACE MONOLAYER THEORY IS INCOMPATIBLE WITH REGIONAL LUNG-FUNCTION, Biophysical journal, 67(3), 1994, pp. 1080-1089
The surface monolayer theory of Clements was tested on open surface fi
lms of calf lung surfactant extract in a leak-free vertical film surfa
ce balance in which alveolar area (A) changes in each lung zone were s
imulated in accordance with the theory. We found that: 1) physiologica
lly necessary low surface tension (gamma), <4 dyn/cm, was sustained on
ly by continuous film compression (''expiration''); 2) compression fro
m A equivalent to total lung capacity to functional residual capacity
produced fleeting gamma reduction in all zones and quick reversal to h
igh gamma with A changes that simulated tidal volume (V-T) breathing a
t both 14 (adult) and 40 (neonatal) cpm; 3) phase differences between
gamma and A axes of V-T loops that indicate mixed surface film composi
tion may be attributable to film inertia and viscoelasticity; 4) estim
ated alveolar retraction pressure due to gamma(P gamma) exceeds ''net'
transpulmonary pressure, i.e., favors alveolar collapse, under virtua
lly all conditions of the theory in all zones; 5) return to transient,
fleeting low gamma in successive V-T cycles was determined by the inh
erent difference in compression and decompression rates, which results
in exhaustion of available A in very few cycles; 6) the ''sigh'', whi
ch restores stable low gamma according to the theory, actually produce
d unstable high gamma during virtually all phases of the maneuver. In
contrast, closed bubble films of the surfactant were structurally stab
le and produce stable near 0 gamma and P gamma.