Cm. Baugh et G. Efstathiou, A COMPARISON OF THE EVOLUTION OF DENSITY FIELDS IN PERTURBATION-THEORY AND NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS .1. NONLINEAR EVOLUTION OF THE POWER SPECTRUM, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 270(1), 1994, pp. 183-198
We present a detailed comparison of the predictions of second-order pe
rturbation theory and numerical N-body simulations for the evolution o
f density fluctuations in a standard cold dark matter universe. The ev
olution of the power spectrum of density perturbations and the two-poi
nt correlation function are studied in the non-linear regime, in order
to determine the range of validity of the perturbation theory approac
h. We conclude that perturbation theory gives a good estimate of the f
orm of the power spectrum as the density field becomes mildly non-line
ar, correctly predicting a transfer of power from larger to smaller sc
ales. We find excellent agreement between the simulation results and p
erturbation theory on length-scales for which the variance of the dens
ity fluctuations is less than or equal to unity. This agreement gradua
lly breaks down as the variance increases above unity. We investigate
the claim made by Couchman & Carlberg, that the standard cold dark mat
ter (CDM) model can be reconciled with observation if the density fiel
d is highly evolved. For a linear variance in the mass density field o
f 1.25, when measured in spheres of radius 8 h-1 Mpc, we find that the
agreement between the standard CDM model and the power spectrum of ga
laxy clustering measured from the APM Survey is improved when non-line
ar effects are included for wavenumbers k less-than-or-equal-to 0.11 h
Mpc-1. The variance in the mass fluctuations on this scale, calculate
d to second order in perturbation theory, is very nearly unity. For wa
venumbers k > 0.11 h Mpc-1, a scale-dependent biasing scheme would be
required, in order to match a standard CDM model with observations of
the galaxy distribution.