Re. Johnson et Bh. Mcfarland, TREATED PREVALENCE RATES OF SEVERE MENTAL-ILLNESS AMONG HMO MEMBERS, Hospital & community psychiatry, 45(9), 1994, pp. 919-924
Objectives, The authors examined the extent to which health maintenanc
e organizations (HMOs) enroll and provide services to PeoPle with seve
re mental illness. Methods: The automated pharmacy system of a large H
MO identified members who had received a Prescription for an antipsych
otic drug or lithium during the two-year study period (1986 and 1987).
These data, combined with data from a 2 percent random sample of HMO
members and from medical records, were used to identify members who sa
tisfied DSM-III-R criteria for schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Tre
ated prevalence rates derived from these data were compared with estim
ated treated prevalence data obtained in the National Institute of Men
tal Health's Epidemiologic Catchment Area (ECA) survey. Results: Altho
ugh methodological complications and small sample sizes precluded a de
tailed comparison, the study found a significantly lower treated preva
lence rate of schizophrenia among HMO members than in the ECA survey.
The treated prevalence rate of bipolar disorder was also lower than th
e ECA rate, but the difference was not significant. Conclusions: The d
ifferences in treated prevalence rates seemed to be the result of diff
erent study methodologies and factors influencing HMO membership. The
results underscore the need for a comprehensive study of the course of
severe mental illness among HMO members.