Cl. Stull et Sp. Mcdonough, MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH TO EVALUATING WELFARE OF VEAL CALVES IN COMMERCIAL FACILITIES, Journal of animal science, 72(9), 1994, pp. 2518-2524
Due to pending legislation and public concerns, a multidisciplinary ap
proach was designed to investigate the welfare of special-fed veal cal
ves in commercial veal facilities. Concerns included housing condition
s, dietary regimens, management practices, and behavioral aspects impo
sed on special-fed calves. Four categories of parameters including env
ironment and housing, nutrition, health and stress, and behavior provi
ded a broad base of evaluating veal systems. Observations and samples
were collected on 550 Holstein bull calves located in 10 commercial ve
al facilities. Each facility was visited to collect data during wk 0 (
week of arrival of the calves), 2, 4, 8, 12, and 16. Nine facilities u
sed individual stalls 48 to 55 cm in width with tethers attached to th
e front of the stalls. One facility housed 30 calves in group pens aft
er obtaining calves at 8 wk of age. Ammonia, carbon monoxide, and hydr
ogen sulfide gas did not exceed the permissible limit for humans in an
y facility. All facilities exceeded the 2-foot-candle recommendation f
or Lighting. The average daily gain of calves was .85 kg during wk 0 t
o 8 and 1.18 kg during wk 8 to 16. Dietary iron levels decreased from
209 ppm at wk 0 to 32 ppm at wk 16. At 16 wk, 25% of calves were margi
nally anemic and 10% clinically anemic. Overall mortality was 4.2%. St
ress indices such as plasma cortisol concentrations or neutrophil to l
ymphocyte ratios declined as calves approached market weight. In eithe
r pens or stalls, calves spent approximately 25 and 75% of time in sta
nding and lying positions, respectively. However, group-penned calves
while recumbent extended one or more legs 13% of time; calves in stall
s extended one or more legs 2% of time. The major factor adversely aff
ecting the welfare of the veal calf was an inadequate immune system on
its arrival to the facility. Quantification of immunoglobulin G level
s indicated that 22% of all calves received adequate transfer of colos
tral immunoglobulins, and 78% had not absorbed sufficient quantities f
rom colostrum and, therefore, were more susceptible to infectious path
ogens. The low mortality rate, rapid growth rate, and absence of stres
s indicators demonstrated the ability of the producer and suitability
of commercial facilities to effectively manage and care for these immu
nologically deficient calves. By comprehensively describing current ma
nagement practices and identifying multidisciplinary factors that infl
uenced the health and welfare of special-fed veal calves in commercial
facilities, the integrated approach provided objective data in respon
se to pending legislation and societal concerns.