Mj. Tucker et al., ASSISTED HATCHING WITH OR WITHOUT BOVINE OVIDUCTAL EPITHELIAL-CELL COCULTURE FOR POOR-PROGNOSIS IN-VITRO FERTILIZATION PATIENTS, Human reproduction, 9(8), 1994, pp. 1528-1531
Older patients and those who consistently return for embryo transfer b
ut without implantation were studied to see if a combination of day 3
assisted hatching and co-culture (AH+CC) might be beneficial compared
to assisted hatching alone (AH-alone). Female patients of greater than
or equal to 38 years and couples who had previously failed to implant
embryos three times or more were prospectively and randomly assigned
to either an experimental or a control group. In the experimental grou
p all embryos were cocultured on partial monolayers of bovine oviducta
l epithelial cells for 2 days followed by assisted hatching by zona dr
illing (AH+CC). All control embryos were cultured by standard procedur
es until day 3 when they also underwent zona drilling prior to uterine
transfer (AH-alone). With 50 cycles in each group there was unfortuna
tely a marginal bias against the AH+CC group in that these patients ha
d undergone a higher number of previous transfer cycles. There was a m
arginally lower percentage of fragmentation and a significantly higher
degree of zona thickness variability in the AH+CC embryo group. Embry
onic implantation was significantly increased (P < 0.05) in the AH+CC
group (18%) when compared to the AH-alone group (10%). This difference
was reflected in a significantly higher (P < 0.05) initial pregnancy
rate (52 versus 32%) in the AH+CC group, and a higher (not significant
) viable pregnancy rate (38 versus 22%).