A biomechanical study was designed to test the hypothesis that isolate
d plantar flexion of the ankle can produce avulsion fractures of the m
edial and lateral malleoli without fracture of the posterior articular
surface of the tibia. Cadaver specimens were subjected to a standard
plantar flexion force in the Burstein torsion testing machine. They sh
owed the following typical patterns of injury in 26 of 32 ankles: (1)
avulsion of the anterior ankle capsule; (2) a short oblique distal fib
ular fracture or fibular avulsion of the anterior talofibular ligament
; and (3) an oblique medial malleolar fracture or a tear of the deep f
ibers of the deltoid ligament. Of particular interest was the directio
n and location of the medial malleolar fracture. This pattern, previou
sly identified with supination-external rotation injuries, was also pr
oduced by isolated plantar flexion, which may be attributed to the ana
tomical attachments of the deltoid ligament on the medial malleolus, a
s well as the position of the foot and direction of the injuring force
.