Am. Elizaga et al., CONTINUOUS REGIONAL ANALGESIA BY INTRANEURAL BLOCK - EFFECT ON POSTOPERATIVE OPIOID REQUIREMENTS AND PHANTOM LIMB PAIN FOLLOWING AMPUTATION, Journal of rehabilitation research and development, 31(3), 1994, pp. 179-187
The objective of this study was to assess the effectiveness of a previ
ously described technique of regional analgesia (continuous infusion o
f local anesthetic through a catheter placed at the time of amputation
within the exposed sciatic or posterior tibial nerve) on relieving th
e postoperative pain in a heterogeneous group of patients who underwen
t lower extremity amputations. A second objective was to determine the
effect of such treatment on the incidence and characteristics of phan
tom limb pain 6 months or more after surgery in the same patients. The
study design was retrospective, unblinded, controlled (postoperative
pain), and unblinded questionnaire and interview (phantom pain) were u
tilized. Subjects were inpatients at Harborview Medical Center, Univer
sity of Washington, Seattle, WA. Nineteen bupivacaine-treated and 40 n
onbupivacaine-treated patients who underwent lower extremity amputatio
n subsequent to trauma, infection, long-standing injury (poor or no fu
nction), congenital deformity, or burns were evaluated in the postoper
ative pain management assessment. Nine treated and 12 untreated patien
ts were interviewed in the phantom pain assessment. Bupivacaine 0.5% 2
-6 ml/h was infused through a polyamide 20-gauge catheter inserted int
o the sciatic or posterior tibial nerve sheath under direct vision at
the time of surgery. All patients, treated and control, received opioi
d analgesics systemically during the 72-hour period of study. The post
operative opioid analgesic requirement of treated patients was compare
d with that of control patients who received opioid analgesics alone.
A questionnaire was administered to assess presence, severity, and cha
racter of phantom pain. The opioid analgesic requirement of treated pa
tients was comparable to that of controls (132.7 ml of morphine equiva
lents/72 h treated; 151.3 ml morphine equivalents/72 h control), as we
re the incidences of all opioid related side effects. The follow-up qu
estionnaire revealed a similar incidence (77% treated; 50% controls) a
nd profile of phantom pain in both groups. In this study, continuous r
egional analgesia by intraneural infusion of local anesthetic failed t
o decrease systemic analgesic requirements or reduce the incidence of
phantom pain compared with standard opioid analgesia. Since two previo
usly published reports have found this technique effective, several po
ssible reasons for the different results of this study are suggested.