The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of a modified Her
bst appliance (mHA) and a muscle relaxation appliance (MR) on nocturna
l breathing and body movement activity in patients with obstructive sl
eep apnoea syndrome (OSAS). To increase the airway space posterior to
the tongue base without severely affecting the craniomandibular joint,
the mHA was adjusted to anchor the mandible at 50% of maximum protrus
ion. MR producing an occlusal coverage but no protrusion served as a c
ontrol appliance. All-night static charge-sensitive bed (SCSB) and fin
ger oximeter recordings were done to six male patients in three condit
ions: first without dental device and then with mHA and with MR, in a
random order, after a 2 month period of habituation. The oxyhaemoglobi
n desaturation events were 44.7h-1 of recording observed during the co
ntrol night, 29.6h-1 with mHA (P = 0.087). The frequency of body movem
ents decreased from 34.9 to 20.4h-1 (P = 0.0079), respectively. MR had
no significant effects either on the frequency of the desaturation ev
ents or the frequency of body movements, but the increased respiratory
resistance breathing, indicating presence of partial upper airway obs
truction, was reduced from 14.3 to 6.9% of the time in bed (P = 0.022)
. We conclude that 50% protrusion chosen for these experiments, produc
ed with a mHA, brought about some alleviation of upper airway obstruct
ion in our preselected patients, but did not lead to sufficient contro
l of apnoea. The reduction of partial upper airway obstruction induced
with a MR warrants further studies in a larger patient population.