Mej. Woolhouse, A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK FOR THE IMMUNOEPIDEMIOLOGY OF BLOCKING ANTIBODIES TO HELMINTH INFECTION, Parasite immunology, 16(8), 1994, pp. 415-424
Epidemiological evidence is widely cited in support of the hypothesis
that certain antibody responses to human helminth, especially schistos
ome, infection exhibit blocking activity. This evidence includes posit
ive correlations between antibody levels and the rate of re-establishm
ent of infection following chemotherapy, antibody levels which peak in
younger and more susceptible age classes, lower ratios of blocking an
tibodies to others in older and less susceptible age classes. In this
paper simple mathematical models are used to explore expected age-spec
ific relationships between antibody levels, parasite burdens and re-es
tablishment rates for different combinations of protective, neutral an
d blocking immune response. In general, all the above cited pattens ma
y be generated without invoking blocking activity, especially if the a
bilities to produce different antibody responses have different immuno
logical memories, i.e. persist for different lengths of time in the ab
sence of continued exposure to antigen. None of these patterns, includ
ing a positive correlation between antibody levels and rates of re-est
ablishment following chemotherapy, offers unambiguous evidence for blo
cking activity. Blocking activity is also predicted to affect the shap
e of the age-intensity curve and the relationship between susceptibili
ty to infection and age in ways which are not necessarily consistent w
ith the epidemiological evidence. The importance of the blocking activ
ity, which has been convincingly demonstrated in vitro, to population
level immunoepidemiological patterns in the field therefore remains un
certain.