Ec. Saw et al., VIDEOTHORACOSCOPIC WEDGE RESECTION FOR PERIPHERAL PULMONARY NODULES, Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 179(3), 1994, pp. 289-294
BACKGROUND: This study was done to evaluate the use of the endoscopic
multifire linear stapler for videothoracoscopic wedge resection (VTWR)
of peripheral pulmonary nodules and to define the indications, advant
ages, and drawbacks of this minimally invasive technique. STUDY DESIGN
: A case study review of 57 consecutive video-assisted thoracic operat
ions for wedge resection of peripheral pulmonary nodules performed upo
n 55 patients admitted to a community hospital from June 1991 through
July 1993 is presented. RESULTS: There were 44 malignant and 13 benign
lesions. Of the malignant peripheral pulmonary nodules (PPN), there w
ere 19 adenocarcinomas, ten squamous cell carcinomas, two undifferenti
ated large-cell carcinomas, three bronchoalveolar carcinomas, two carc
inoid tumors, one neuroendocrine tumor, and seven metastatic carcinoma
s. The benign nodules included five hamartomas, two granulomas, one as
pergilloma, one nodular amyloidosis, one Wegener's granulomatosis, one
focal pulmonary infarct, and two interstitial fibroses. Videothoracos
copic wedge resection alone was performed upon 37 patients, 17 of whom
had primary carcinoma of the lung; seven had metastatic lesions, and
the remainder had benign disease. Of the 17 patients with primary carc
inoma of the lung who had VTWR alone, eight patients had marked impair
ment of pulmonary function, six had significant co-morbid disease, two
had peripheral carcinoid tumors, and one had bilateral metachronous c
arcinomas. Videothoracoscopic wedge resections with concomitant lobect
omies were performed upon 20 patients with primary carcinoma of the lu
ng, including one patient with bilateral synchronous carcinomas. Five
of the patients with nodules ranging from 2 to 3 cm in diameter were f
ound to have metastasis to regional nodes. None of the patients who ha
d lobectomies for peripheral carcinomas less than 2 cm in diameter had
regional nodal metastases. There was no perioperative mortality and n
o significant morbidity. CONCLUSIONS: Videothoracoscopic wedge resecti
on is a useful alternative to traditional transthoracic resection for
suspicious, undiagnosed PPN, for low grade malignant neoplasms, such a
s carcinoid, for peripheral metastatic lesions, for bilateral synchron
ous or metachronous tumors, for the occasional clinically localized pe
ripheral small-cell carcinoma as a surgical adjunct to chemotherapy, a
nd for small, peripheral, T-1, N-0, M-0 bronchial carcinomas in compro
mised patients at high risk with marginal pulmonary reserve. The proce
dure is effective, minimally invasive, and has potential advantages ov
er conventional thoracotomy, including less postoperative pain and mor
bidity, shorter hospitalization period and convalescence, and an earli
er return to work and normal activities.