Tj. Lensmire et De. Beals, APPROPRIATING OTHERS WORDS - TRACES OF LITERATURE AND PEER CULTURE INA 3RD-GRADERS WRITING, Language in society, 23(3), 1994, pp. 411-426
Mikhail Bakhtin's notion of appropriation is a potentially powerful wa
y to conceptualize discourse development in children. Typically, studi
es of discourse development have emphasized structural aspects of text
. However, children appropriate not only forms, but also words, themes
, purposes, and styles. From a developmental point of view, the concep
t of appropriation raises at least three questions: What is it that ch
ildren appropriate? Where do they get their material? And what do they
do with that material? In an attempt to make sense of appropriation a
s a developmental construct, we examine one third-grader's writing: Su
zanne's book, The missing piece. We find that Suzanne appropriated mat
erial from two major sources: (a) adult-authored text - Margaret Sidne
y's novel, Five little Peppers and how they grew - and (b) the meaning
s and values of a stratified local peer culture. We conclude by discus
sing the significance of this work for future research on children's d
iscourse development.