Rh. Okland et O. Eilertsen, CANONICAL CORRESPONDENCE-ANALYSIS WITH VARIATION PARTITIONING - SOME COMMENTS AND AN APPLICATION, Journal of vegetation science, 5(1), 1994, pp. 117-126
This study presents an alternative treatment of data from a comprehens
ive vegetation study in which the main gradient structure of boreal co
niferous forest vegetation in southern Norway was investigated by ordi
nation techniques. The data sets include vegetation samples of differe
nt plot sizes, supplied with measurements of 33 environmental explanat
ory variables (classified in four groups) and nine spatial explanatory
variables derived from geographical coordinates. Partitioning the var
iation of the species-sample plot matrices on different sets of explan
atory variables is performed by use of (partial) Canonical Corresponde
nce Analysis. Several aspects of vegetation-environment relationships
in the investigation area are discussed on the basis of results obtain
ed by the new method. Generally, ca. 35 % of the variation in species
abundances are explained by environmental and spatial variables. The r
esults indicate support for the hypothesis of macro-scale topographic
control over the differentiation of the vegetation, more strongly so i
n pine than in spruce forest where soil nutrients play a major role. T
owards finer scales, the primary topographical and topographically dep
endent factors lose importance, and vegetational differentiation is mo
re strongly affected by the accumulated effects of the vegetation (inc
luding the tree stand) on soils, shading, litter fall, etc. The fracti
on of variation in species abundance explained by significant environm
ental variables was found to be ca. twice as large as the fraction exp
lained by spatial variables. The fraction of variation explained by th
e supplied variables differed between data sets; it was lower for cryp
togams than for vascular plants, and lower for smaller than for larger
sample plots. Possible reasons for these patterns are discussed. Some
methodological aspects of CCA with variation partitioning are discuss
ed: improvements, necessary precautions, and the advantages over alter
native methods.