M. Tayles et C. Drury, NEW MANUFACTURING TECHNOLOGIES AND MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS - SOME EVIDENCE OF THE PERCEPTIONS OF UK MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING PRACTITIONERS, International journal of production economics, 36(1), 1994, pp. 1-17
During the 1980s European manufacturing companies faced significant an
d radical changes in both manufacturing technologies and the level and
nature of competition. Critics have argued that management accounting
has hindered rather than helped these changes to come about. It is cl
aimed that management accounting has failed to make visible and theref
ore governable the detailed work processes of a modern manufacturing o
rganisation. Most of the literature relating to the impact of advanced
manufacturing technologies (AMTs) on management accounting systems re
sults from the views expressed by academics rather than management acc
ountants working in an AMT environment. To remedy this deficiency and
to ascertain the extent to which management accounting systems have ch
anged or are likely to change a questionnaire survey was undertaken wh
ich sought to obtain the perceptions of and practices adopted by exper
ienced management accountants in UK manufacturing companies. The paper
reports on the systems in current use for costing, performance measur
ement, control and investment appraisal. It incorporates the opinions
of practitioners on a range of common assertions relating to the moder
n manufacturing and competitive environment and through the use of ope
n-ended questions provides the opportunity for direct practitioner inp
ut to the debate on the relevance of management accounting. The paper
enables some conclusions to be drawn but also raises important questio
ns on the extent to which manufacturing is hindered by inappropriate o
r delayed development of management accounting systems.