The proposed disease controlling antirheumatic therapy (DC-ART) defini
tion requires that the therapy change the course of rheumatoid arthrit
is (RA) for at least 1 year, evidenced by (1) sustained improvement in
physical function, (2) decreased inflammatory synovitis, and (3) slow
ing or prevention of structural joint damage. Selected studies are rev
iewed. All studies were at least 1 year in duration, but most did not
include all 3 of the DC-ART requirements. In these studies, patients t
reated with placebo generally had no improvement in inflammatory synov
itis and progressive structural joint damage, judged by serial joint r
adiographs. A minority of studies significantly favored one or another
of the available agents (gold injections, D-penicillamine, auranofin,
antimalarials, azathioprine, sulfasalazine, methotrexate), but the ev
idence for any one agent is not convincing. For future DC-ART clinical
trials patients with early RA should be studied. A hybrid study desig
n may be useful, combining an initial double blind randomized controll
ed clinical trial with continuing longterm observation of all withdraw
als using specified clinical, radiographic, and self report assessment
s at regular intervals, and an intent-to-treat analysis comparing long
term response rates of the original control and experimental therapy g
roups. Responsive subgroups should be sought, their characteristics id
entified, and their responsiveness confirmed in additional trials limi
ted to the identified subgroup.