E. Hauptman et al., DESIGN AND STUDY OF RH(III) CATALYSTS FOR THE SELECTIVE TAIL-TO-TAIL DIMERIZATION OF METHYL ACRYLATE, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 116(18), 1994, pp. 8038-8060
The development of an efficient, highly selective Rh(III) catalyst sys
tem for the tail-to-tail dimerization of methyl acrylate (MA) to dimet
hyl hexenedioates, precursors to adipic acid, is described. The cataly
tic cycle is entered by protonation of CpRh(C2H4)(2)l(Cp* = C(5)Me(5)
) to yield CpRh(C2H4) (CH2CH2-mu-H)(+) (7) followed by reaction with
methylacrylate. The catalyst resting state has been generated by low-t
emperature protonation of CpRh(CH2CHCO2-CH3)(2)l (15) and identified
as CpRd(CH(2)CH(2)COOMe)(eta(2)-CH(2)CHCO(2)Me)(+) (8) by H-1 and C-1
3 NMR spectroscopy. Investigation of iridium analogs has led to the is
olation and X-ray structural characterization of CpIr(CH(2)CH(2)COOMe
)(eta(2)-CH(2)CHCO(2)Me)(+) (23a), in which the orientation of the acr
ylate ligands is that required for tail-to-tail coupling. At -23 degre
es C, complex 8 undergoes beta-migratory insertion to give CpRhCH(CH(
2)COOMe)(CH2-CH(2)COOMe)(+) (10). Complex 10 was independently synthes
ized by treatment of complex 7 with trans-MeO(2)CCH=CHCH(2)CH(2)CO(2)M
e and was characterized by X-ray crystallography. The free energy of a
ctivation for the migration reaction is 18.7 kcal/mol and matches that
based on the catalytic turnover (TO) frequency (6.6 TO/min at 25 degr
ees C, Delta G = 19 kcal/mol). This observation confirms 8 as the res
ting state and the C-C coupling reaction as the turnover-limiting step
. The catalyst deactivates by formal loss of Hz from complex 10 to pro
duce CpRh(eta(3)-CH3OCOCH2CHCHCHCO2CH3)(+) (9). The structure of comp
lex 9 was verified by an X-ray crystallographic study. Exposure of 9 t
o an atmosphere of H-2 in the presence of MA regenerates the resting s
tate 8, and dimerization proceeds. Second generation catalysts with in
creased activity and lifetimes have been developed by replacing the C(
5)Me(5) ligand by methylated indenyl ligands. Using the catalytic syst
em derived from (1,2,3-trimethylindenyl)Rh(C2H4>(2) (11), conversion o
f 54 000 equiv of methyl acrylate to dimethyl hexenedioates could be a
chieved after 68 h at 55 OC under N-2. Details of the mechanism have b
een elucidated and resemble closely those of the Cp system. Similar i
ntermediates to 8 and 10 have been characterized by H-1 and C-13 NMR s
pectroscopy. In contrast, treatment with methyl acrylate of the more e
lectrophilic systems derived from CpRh(C2H4)(2) (25) (Cp = C5H5) and C
pRh(C2H4)(2) (30) (Cp* = C-5(CH3)(4)CF3) results in slow dimerization
. Low-temperature protonation of CpRh(CH2CHCO2CH3)(2) (27) with H(Et(2
)O)(2)BAr'(4) yields a mixture of rhodium species which upon warming t
o 23 degrees C converge to the bis-chelate complex CpRhCH(CH(2)COOMe)(
CH(2)CH(2)COOMe)(+) (28). Exposure of complex 28 to MA generates the u
nusual bridged species CpRh(CH2CHCOOCH3)H(CH2CHCOOCH3)(+) (29), which
serves as the resting state during dimerization. Treatment of complex
30 with H(Et(2)O)(2)BAr'(4) yields CpRh(C2H4)(CH2CH2-mu-H)(+) (31), w
hich upon reaction with MA clearly produces CpRhCH(CH(2)COOMe)(CH(2)C
H(2)COOMe)(+) (33), and dimerization proceeds. Finally, attempts to ca
talyze the dimerization of other functionalized olefins including meth
yl vinyl ketone, methyl crotonate, 2-vinylpyridine, and 1-vinyl-2-pyrr
olidinone are presented.