Health effects associated with sodium-cycle water softening has led to
the consideration of potassium-cycle ion exchange as an attractive al
ternative. Regulatory agencies, however, have expressed concern regard
ing the environmental impacts associated with discharge of potassium-l
aden brine. To assist in providing guidance regarding the relative env
ironmental impacts deriving from discharge of sodium- and potassium-cy
cle softener regeneration brine, this article summarizes available lit
erature exploring systems potentially impacted by brine discharge. The
literature indicates that replacing sodium chloride with potassium ch
loride as a water softener regenerant appears to result in a more envi
ronmentally benign scenario and may, in certain circumstances, be envi
ronmentally beneficial. Some areas where potassium chloride may be adv
antageous are land application of sewage sludge, viral inactivation, m
obility in soil, effects on soil properties and impacts on plant life.
There are no significant differences between sodium chloride and pota
ssium chloride in effect on engineered physicochemical processes of in
inaquatic life systems. The impact of sodium may be detrimental to th
e environment because the uptake of phosphorus by algae was reportedly
enhanced by sodium. Potassium, on the other hand, was not reported to
enhance phosphorous uptake. Some questions remain about the impact of
potassium and sodium on septic tank bacteria, biological waste treatm
ent processes, and effects on natural flora. The literature reviewed o
n these topics was somewhat conflicting. Further efforts to assess the
impact of potassium and sodium should be directed at resolving these
literature discrepancies.