We examine the predictions for nuclear charge radii made by an extende
d Thomas-Fermi mass formula, the first to be built entirely on microsc
opic forces, and the finite-range droplet model mass formula, the most
refined of the droplet-model approaches. The former is highly success
ful, the parameters emerging from the mass fit giving an optimal fit t
o charge radii also, without any further adjustment. The latter model
in its published form seems to suffer from an inappropriate choice for
the values of some of the parameters, and we discuss how improvement
might be possible.