SPATIAL VARIATION IN THE N-15 AND C-13 STABLE-ISOTOPE COMPOSITION OF PLANTS, INVERTEBRATES AND FISHES ON MEDITERRANEAN REEFS - IMPLICATIONSFOR THE STUDY OF TROPHIC PATHWAYS
S. Jennings et al., SPATIAL VARIATION IN THE N-15 AND C-13 STABLE-ISOTOPE COMPOSITION OF PLANTS, INVERTEBRATES AND FISHES ON MEDITERRANEAN REEFS - IMPLICATIONSFOR THE STUDY OF TROPHIC PATHWAYS, Marine ecology. Progress series, 146(1-3), 1997, pp. 109-116
delta(15)N and delta(13)C were determined for plants, invertebrates an
d fishes collected from 3 sites on the southern coast of the Mediterra
nean island of Mallorca, Spain. The sites were separated by distances
of 1250 to 3750 m. The mean delta(15)N of plants was 1.1 to 4.1 parts
per thousand, benthic invertebrates 5.9 to 6.9 parts per thousand, pla
nktonic invertebrates 5.5 to 5.8 parts per thousand and fishes 8.4 to
13.8 parts per thousand. delta(15)N became enriched with increasing tr
ophic level. The mean delta(13)C of plants was -11.4 to -16.3 parts pe
r thousand, benthic invertebrates -14.8 to -16.8 parts per thousand, p
lanktonic invertebrates -19.3 to -19.8 parts per thousand and fishes -
16.1 to -19.2 parts per thousand. There were significant differences i
n the isotopic composition of individual species within the plant, inv
ertebrate or fish groupings at each site and there were significant di
fferences in the isotopic composition of the same species at different
sites. Depleted C-13 was associated with benthic food chains and enri
ched C-13 with planktonic chains. The data suggest that benthic food c
hains are important to the rocky reef associated fishes studied, as mi
ght be expected in a nutrient poor system where planktonic production
is relatively low. However, the variance in delta(13)C composition bet
ween sites was such that the relative significance of the 2 pathways c
ould not be determined. N-15 measurements indicated that some of the f
ish species studied had adopted different feeding strategies at differ
ent sites and,as a result, individuals of the same species could somet
imes be assigned to different trophic groups at different sites. The d
ata suggest that these fishes exhibit plasticity in their feeding stra
tegies and this may provide them with greater adaptive flexibility to
respond to site-specific changes in food availability, Moreover, the d
ata provide empirical support for current theories of food web dynamic
s which suggest that trophic 'levels' are dynamic rather than fixed an
d that 'multichannel omnivory' is an important feature of food webs.