Md. Webber et al., PLANT UPTAKE OF PCBS AND OTHER ORGANIC CONTAMINANTS FROM SLUDGE-TREATED COAL REFUSE, Journal of environmental quality, 23(5), 1994, pp. 1019-1026
A field study of industrial organic contaminant uptake, in particular
PCB uptake, by growing crops was conducted during 1990 at the St. Davi
d Coal Refuse Pile Reclamation Site, Fulton County, Illinois. The site
had received one-time applications in 1987 of 785, 1570 and 3360 Mg h
a-1 dry wt. of Chicago municipal sewage sludge. Corn (Zea mays L.), ca
bbage (Brassica oleracea capitata L.), and carrot (Daucus carota L.) w
ere grown on the sludge treatments and soil (i.e., sludge treated coal
refuse) and plant samples were analyzed. Mean PCB concentrations in t
he soils were less-than-or-equal-to 4 mg kg-1 dry wt. and there was no
consistent effect on them of sludge application rate. Measurements on
the 3360 Mg ha-1 dry wt. of sludge treatment soil indicated that seve
ral organochlorine pesticides occurred at concentrations less-than-or-
equal-to 217 mug kg-1 dry wt. and several polynuclear aromatic hydroca
rbons occurred at <1 to 3 mg kg-1 dry wt. Mean PCB concentrations in t
he plant materials were <300 mug kg-1 dry wt., however, there were dif
ferences among and within crops. Concentrations decreased in the order
: carrot peels > carrot tops > cabbage wrapper and inner leaves > carr
ot core > corn ear leaf and stover > corn grain. There was insignifica
nt PCB in corn grain. Except for cabbage wrapper leaves, the PCB conce
ntrations in plant materials were not related to those in soil. Soil P
CB concentrations accounted for 24% of the variance in cabbage wrapper
leaf PCB concentrations and the bioconcentration factor (mg PCB kg-1
dry wt. of leaf/kg PCB ha-1 dry wt. of soil) was 0.0042. There was no
detection of organochlorine pesticides in plant materials grown on the
3360 Mg ha-1 dry wt. of sludge treatment soil and, except for indole
and isophorone, only trace amounts of a very few other organic contami
nants were observed in the plant materials. Indole ranging from no det
ection to 52 mg kg-1 dry wt. may have been a natural constituent of ca
bbage. Isophorone ranging from 14 to 79 mg kg-1 dry wt. was observed i
n three samples of cabbage wrapper leaves and its source is unknown. D
espite the very large rates of Chicago sludge employed in this study,
findings indicated that they did not (i) result in high levels of orga
nic contamination in the treated coal refuse, and (ii) represent a sig
nificant organic contaminant hazard to the quality for food and feedst
uffs of crops grown on the treated coal refuse.