Wg. Harris et al., DAIRY MANURE INFLUENCE ON SOIL AND SEDIMENT COMPOSITION - IMPLICATIONS FOR PHOSPHORUS RETENTION, Journal of environmental quality, 23(5), 1994, pp. 1071-1081
Manure-derived P can jeopardize surface water quality in regions domin
ated by sandy soils, due to low P retention capacity of these soils. S
urface (Ap) horizons from dairy-intensive areas in the Lake Okeechobee
Basin were recently found to release P readily, despite abundant Ca a
nd high pH. The purpose of this study was to determine the inorganic c
omponents that influence or reflect the stability of P in these horizo
ns and in a related stream sediment that released much less P than soi
l material, despite comparable total P. Coarse fragments (>2 mm), sand
, silt, and clay were separated by sieving and centrifugation. Whole s
oil material and coarse fragments were examined using a dissecting mic
roscope. Crystalline and noncrystalline components were identified usi
ng a combination of optical microscopy, x-ray diffraction, scanning el
ectron microscopy, energy dispersive x-ray analysis, electron micropro
be analysis, thermogravimetry, density separation, and selective disso
lution techniques. The >2-mum fraction of Ap horizons was dominated by
quartz, but appreciable biogenic opal was present in the silt. Clay f
rom these horizons was mainly noncrystalline Si (opal A), which persis
ted after Ca and P were removed via selective dissolution. The clay-fr
action Si had high CEC, abundant adsorbed water, amorphous morphology,
and low affinity for P. It was probably a degradation product of opal
ine forage phytoliths, since dried manure contained Si bodies similar
in morphology to those found in silt and clay. Lack of Ca-P minerals s
uggests that manure components (i.e., organic acids, Mg, Si, etc.) inh
ibited crystallization of stable Ca-P, thereby maintaining high P solu
bility. The stream sediment contained a calcium phosphate mineral rese
mbling poorly crystalline apatite, and a ferrous phosphate mineral (vi
vianite). The flux of P from dairy to aquatic systems in regions of do
minantly sandy soils could be markedly reduced if the barrier to the c
rystallization of Ca-P could be eliminated.