Re. Tremblay et al., PREDICTING EARLY-ONSET OF MALE ANTISOCIAL-BEHAVIOR FROM PRESCHOOL BEHAVIOR, Archives of general psychiatry, 51(9), 1994, pp. 732-739
Methods: Data from a large longitudinal study of boys who were between
kindergarten and age 13 years were used to (1) test whether Gray's an
d Cloninger's personality dimensions measured in kindergarten predicte
d the early onset of stable, highly delinquent behavior; (2) test whet
her 1, 2, or 3 dimensions were needed; and (3) test the predictive val
ue of a categorical approach. Results: The impulsivity dimension was t
he best predictor of the early onset of stable, highly delinquent beha
vior. Anxiety and reward dependence made significant but weaker contri
butions. The categorical approach corroborated Cloninger's suggestion
that boys who are high in impulsivity, low in anxiety, and low in rewa
rd dependence would be more at risk for delinquent involvement. Boys w
ho were high in impulsivity and low in anxiety but high in reward depe
ndence were much less at risk for delinquency. Differences in antisoci
al behavior among extreme kindergarten personality groups were stable
from ages 11 to 13 years. Conclusions: The behavioral activating syste
m appears to be the major dimension underlying the propensity toward e
arly onset of antisocial behavior, but both the behavioral inhibition
system and the need for social rewards play important roles. The behav
ioral style (personality) that results from the interplay of these sys
tems is clearly in place by the kindergarten year. Preventive efforts
should target preschool children with at-risk behavior profiles. Howev
er, longitudinal-experimental studies with at least yearly assessments
between birth and school-entry age are needed to understand the exten
t to which the behavioral styles are antecedent to preschool disruptiv
e behavior disorders.