Tm. Poland et Jh. Borden, ATTACK DYNAMICS OF IPS-PINI (SAY) AND PITYOGENES-KNECHTELI (SWAINE) (COL, SCOLYTIDAE) IN WINDTHROWN LODGEPOLE PINE TREES, Journal of applied entomology, 117(5), 1994, pp. 434-443
The pine engraver, Ips pini Say, is a pest of lodgepole pine, Pinus co
ntorta var. latifolia Engelman. It usually infests dead or weakened tr
ees but at high population densities can kill standing trees. Pityogen
es knechteli Swaine often co-exists with I. pini, but is not economica
lly important. Our objective was to test the hypothesis that competiti
ve interactions between P. knechteli and I. pini may adversely affect
the success of I. pini in lodgepole pine. This hypothesis was tested b
y: 1) investigating the relationship between emergence hole of the two
species in naturally-infested hosts; and 2) comparing the attack dyna
mics of both species alone and together in naturally-infested windthro
wn trees. There was a strong, non-linear inverse relationship between
emergence holes of I. pini and P. knechteli. Emergence hole densities
of I. pini and P. knechteli were positively and negatively correlated,
respectively, with tree diameter. These results suggest that high num
bers of one species are associated with low numbers of the other, and
that beetles in the two species tend to partition the shared resource
according to its diameter. There was a slight negative effect on the s
uccess of beetles in both species in naturally-infested, co-attacked t
rees. It appears that I. pini and P. knechteli can co-exist within the
same host tree in part because of a lack of exploitative competition,
and also because beetles in the two species partition the phloem reso
urce so as to minimize competitive interactions. While P. knechteli wo
uld be of limited practical potential in competitive displacement of I
. pini, its ability to coinfest hosts with I. pini may enhance the adv
erse effect of I. pini on the mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponde
rosae Hopkins.