Re. Krupp, PHASE-RELATIONS AND PHASE-TRANSFORMATIONS BETWEEN THE LOW-TEMPERATUREIRON SULFIDES MACKINAWITE, GREIGITE, AND SMYTHITE, European journal of mineralogy, 6(2), 1994, pp. 265-278
Studies on natural smythite (Fe13S16), greigite (Fe3S4), and mackinawi
te (FeS1-x) from the low-temperature hydrothermal Moschellandsberg mer
cury deposit (SW-Germany) revealed oriented replacements and overgrowt
hs of greigite and mackinawite by smythite. Microprobe analyses show t
hat the iron sulfides are essentially pure iron end-members. Thus smyt
hite is a phase in the pure Fe-S system, and no minor elements in soli
d solution are required to stabilize it. The oriented replacements can
be interpreted in part as a recrystallization process and in part as
solid-state transformations, driven by disequilibrium between phases a
nd by probable metastability of greigite and mackinawite. The observed
reactions involve minor changes in the Fe/S ratios which were probabl
y facilitated by iron exchange with the siderite matrix. As a conseque
nce of the observed phase transformations it is suggested that smythit
e is stable, and that pyrrhotites (except troilite) may be metastable
at temperatures below 65-degrees-C.