Differences among corn (Zea mays L.) hybrids for forage quality traits
have been reported, but the stability of forage quality differences o
ver diverse environments is not well documented. To evaluate hybrid st
ability for yield and forage quality, nine commercial hybrids were eva
luated at two locations in Pennsylvania in 1990 and one location in 19
91. All hybrids were harvested on the same day at the 2/3 milk line to
black layer stage, depending on the hybrid. Whole plant and stover su
bsamples were collected from each plot, chopped, dried, and ground for
analysis. Forage analysis for crude protein (CP), acid detergent fibe
r (ADF), neutral detergent fiber (NDF), and in vitro dry matter disapp
earance (IVDMD) was performed using near infrared reflectance spectros
copy (NIRS) on both whole plant and stover samples. Total digestible n
utrients (TDN) was calculated based on the ADF concentration. Environm
ental effects were significant for yield and all quality traits. Hybri
d effects were significant for all traits except TDN, ADF, and NDF. Th
e range among hybrids for whole plant IVDMD at individual locations wa
s as high as 4.1 percentage units, but averaged over the three environ
ments, the range among hybrids was 2.7 percentage units. Silage yield
differences among hybrids, which ranged up to 2.6 tons/acre or 11.5% o
f the mean, were larger on a percentage basis than any of the quality
differences. The results of this study indicate that both yield and fo
rage quality differences exist among commercial hybrids and that produ
cers should consider both yield and quality attributes in selecting a
hybrid for silage production.