Rr. Delongchamp et al., CANCER MORTALITY AMONG ATOMIC-BOMB SURVIVORS EXPOSED IN-UTERO OR AS YOUNG-CHILDREN, OCTOBER 1950 MAY 1992, Radiation research, 147(3), 1997, pp. 385-395
Cancer mortality for the period from October 1950 through May 1992 was
analyzed in atomic bomb survivors exposed in utero. Risk estimates fo
r this group were also compared to those for survivors who were less t
han 6 years old at the time of exposure. The cohorts studied include 8
07 in utero survivors and 5,545 persons exposed during childhood with
all members of both groups having estimated doses of at least 0.01 Sv.
The comparison group includes 10,453 persons with little (< 0.01 Sv)
or no exposure. Analyses were limited mainly to cancer deaths occurrin
g between the ages of 17 and 46. Only 10 cancer deaths were observed a
mong persons exposed in utero. However, there is a significant dose re
sponse with an estimate of excess relative risk per sievert (ERR/Sv) o
f 2.1 (90% confidence interval of 0.2 to 6.0). This estimate does not
differ significantly from that for survivors exposed during the first
5 years of life. The cancer deaths among those exposed in utero involv
ed leukemia (2), female-specific organs (3) and digestive organs (5).
Nine deaths occurred in females, where the excess risk for all solid c
ancers has a 90% confidence interval on the ERR/Sv of 1.6 to 17. Signi
ficant risks were found for cancers of the digestive system [90% confi
dence interval (CI) on the ERR/Sv of 0.7 to 20] and for female-specifi
c cancers (90% CI on the ERR/SV of 0.7 to 42). These risks do not diff
er significantly from those seen in females exposed as children. There
were no deaths from solid cancer in men exposed in utero. The ERR/Sv
has an upper 95% confidence bound of 2.5 which does not differ from th
at for exposed children, where the upper 95% confidence bound is 1.5.
The sexes differ even when female-specific cancers are excluded from t
he comparison. Although there were only two leukemia deaths among thos
e exposed in utero, the leukemia death rate for this group is higher t
han that in the comparison group (P = 0.054) with an exposure effect t
hat is about half the magnitude and not significantly different from t
hat seen after childhood exposure (P = 0.103). However, there is no ev
idence of a dose response among those exposed in utero because no high
-dose leukemia deaths were observed, a result that differs considerabl
y from that for those exposed as children. There is a need for caution
in the interpretation of these data. First, the number of cancer deat
hs is small; second, there is unexplained significant difference in th
e mortality from solid cancer between the sexes; and third, the excess
of leukemia in those exposed in utero is not reflected in an increasi
ng dose response. (C) 1997 by Radiation Research Society.