Mv. Nezlin et Gg. Sutyrin, PROBLEMS OF SIMULATION OF LARGE, LONG-LIVED VORTICES IN THE ATMOSPHERES OF THE GIANT PLANETS (JUPITER, SATURN, NEPTUNE), Surveys in geophysics, 15(1), 1994, pp. 63-99
Large, long-lived vortices are abundant in the atmospheres of the gian
t planets. Some of them survive a few orders of magnitude longer than
the dispersive linear Rossby wave packets, e,g. the Great Red Spot (GR
S), Little Red Spot (LRS) and White Ovals (WO) of Jupiter, Big Bertha,
Brown Spot and Anne's Spot of Saturn, the Great Dark Spot (GDS) of Ne
ptune, etc. Nonlinear effects which prevent their dispersion spreading
are the main subject of our consideration. Particular emphasis is pla
ced on determining the dynamical processes which may explain the remar
kable properties of observed vortices such as anticyclonic rotation in
preference to cyclonic one and the uniqueness of the GRS, the largest
coherent vortex, along the perimeter of Jupiter at corresponding lati
tude. We review recent experimental and theoretical studies of steadil
y translating solitary Rossby vortices (anticyclones) in a rotating sh
allow fluid. Two-dimensional monopolar solitary vortices trap fluid wh
ich is transported westward. These dualistic structures appear to be v
ortices, on the one hand, and solitary ''waves'', on the other hand. O
wing to the presence of the trapped fluid, such solitary structures co
llide inelastically and have a memory of the initial disturbance which
is responsible for the formation of the structure. As a consequence,
they have no definite relationship between the amplitude and character
istic size. Their vortical properties are connected with geostrophic a
dvection of local vorticity. Their solitary properties (nonspreading a
nd stationary translation) are due to a balance between Rossby wave di
spersion and nonlinear effects which allow the anticyclones, with an e
levation of a free surface, to propagate faster than the linear waves,
without a resonance with linear waves, i.e. without wave radiation. O
n the other hand, cyclones, with a depression of a free surface, are d
ispersive and nonstationary features. This asymmetry in dispersion-non
linear properties of cyclones and anticyclones is thought to be one of
the essential reasons for the observed predominance of anticyclones a
mong the long-lived vortices in the atmospheres of the giant planets a
nd also among the intrathermocline oceanic eddies. The effects of shea
r flows and differences between the properties of monopolar vortices i
n planetary flows and various laboratory experiments are discussed. Ge
neral geostrophic (GG) theory of Rossby vortices is presented. It diff
ers essentially from the traditional quasi-geostrophic (QG) and interm
ediate-geostrophic (IG) approximations by the account of (i) all scale
s between the deformation radius and the planetary scale and (ii) the
arbitrary amplitudes of vortices. It is shown that, unlike QG- and IG-
models, the GG-model allows for explaining the mentioned cyclonic-anti
cyclonic asymmetry not only in planetary flows, but also in laboratory
modeling with vessels of near paraboloidal form.