Ta. Rich et Ja. Ajani, HIGH-DOSE EXTERNAL-BEAM RADIATION-THERAPY WITH OR WITHOUT CONCOMITANTCHEMOTHERAPY FOR ESOPHAGEAL-CARCINOMA, Annals of oncology, 5, 1994, pp. 190000009-190000015
Esophageal cancer patients treated with radiotherapy (RTx) are most of
ten those with malignancies too extensive for surgery or those who dee
med medically unsuitable for an aggressive surgical approach. Summariz
ing RTx series, the 2-year survival rate is in the range of 10% and at
5 years about 5%. Although not randomly compared, these results are n
ot significantly worse than those achieved with surgery in more advanc
ed tumors. In stage I/II tumors, more recent trials reported of 5-year
survival rates varying between 12% and 20%. These data indicate that
irradiation may be administered with curative intention but usually on
ly for patients who are also candidates for primary surgery. On the ot
her hand, modern RTx (doses > 60 Gy) +/- endoluminal after-loading may
provide good palliation (relief of dysphagia) for patients with good
prognostic factors such as weight loss of less than 10% body weight, g
ood performance status, younger age, and location of the tumor. In the
perioperative setting, RTx reduced the frequency of the local recurre
nces but did not increase the overall resection and R0 resection rates
and did not improve survival due to more patients relapsing at distan
t sites. Combined chemoradiotherapy has shown to be superior to RTx al
one with respect to local control, disease free survival and overall s
urvival and in a marked reduction of distant failures. These data supp
ort the use of chemoradiotherapy as standard treatment of locally adva
nced and nonresectable esophageal cancer. They also provide a basis fo
r randomized trials comparing chemoradiotherapy alone versus preoperat
ive treatment modalities.