Bj. Reilly et Mj. Kyj, META-ETHICAL REASONING - APPLIED TO ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS PRINCIPLES, The American journal of economics and sociology, 53(2), 1994, pp. 147-162
Ethics and ethical thinking involve two primary and interdependent ele
ments of analysis: the individual and the society. Economic thought di
chotomized these two elements into the individual (competitive capital
ism) or the society (Marxist socialism), with one element being the ca
use, and the other the effect. Views of economic reality were develope
d not on the basis of the interdependence of the individual and the so
ciety but their mutual antagonism. Economic thought is based on the sc
ientific reasoning of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Its ab
stract definition of reality narrowed the significance of the concrete
appearances of things in favor of the rules (science) that define thi
ngs. Science requires both an objective causal order (independent of h
uman definitions and beliefs) and the development of laws (independent
of the human observer or participant) that explain the nature of the
objective world. Ethical reasoning requires that economic causality be
defined to include both the individual and the society. Ethical reaso
ning is needed to bring together both the scientific and the metaphysi
cal for human meaning. The science of means must be joined to the huma
n purposes of ends.