Jj. Ague, MASS-TRANSFER DURING BARROVIAN METAMORPHISM OF PELITES, SOUTH-CENTRALCONNECTICUT .1. EVIDENCE FOR CHANGES IN COMPOSITION AND VOLUME, American journal of science, 294(8), 1994, pp. 989-1057
Evidence for mass and volume changes attending the Barrovian (chlorite
to kyanite zone) metamorphism of aluminous pelites of the Wepawaug Sc
hist, Connecticut, is examined using a petrologic mass balance approac
h that takes full account of the closure problem and the multivariate
nature of compositional data. Quartz veins are not included in the ana
lysis so that mass and volume changes in aluminous pelite can be effec
tively isolated and quantified. Statistical analysis and regional mapp
ing of chemistry and density variations strongly suggest that the phys
icochemical properties of the pelites are correlated with geographic p
osition and metamorphic grade. The nature and degree of the variations
indicate that they are the result of metamorphism, not sedimentary or
diagenetic processes. The concentration systematics of relatively ''i
mmobile'' low-solubility elements (for example, Ti, Zr, and Nb) are co
nsistent with the hypothesis that the garnet, staurolite, and kyanite
zone pelites had initial (protolith) compositions that were comparable
to those of the presently exposed chlorite and biotite zone rocks. Ma
ss balance analysis strongly suggests that metamorphism led to signifi
cant mass and volume changes over minimum length scales on the order o
f typical hand sample dimensions. The average degree of physicochemica
l change increases in a general way with metamorphic grade. Average to
tal mass change estimates, computed relative to the low-grade chlorite
and biotite zone rocks using a Ti reference frame, are -10 +/- 9 perc
ent, -19 +/- 6 percent, and -23 +/- 6 percent for the garnet, stauroli
te, and kyanite zone pelites, respectively (+/-2sigma; negative values
indicate mass loss). A diverse spectrum of elements were apparently m
obile during metamorphism. Si was lost from upper greenschist and amph
ibolite facies pelites; average silica mass change values are -15(14)17 percent, -32(-9)+11 percent, and -38(-8)+9 percent for the garnet,
staurolite, and kyanite zones, respectively (+/- 2sigma). P was lost f
rom kyanite zone pelites, and Na was lost from the amphibolite facies
pelites. On average, Mn and Zn were added to staurolite and kyanite zo
ne pelites, and K and Ba were added to staurolite zone pelites. Amphib
olite facies pelites may have lost some Ca and Sr, but the analysis is
complicated by protolith heterogeneity. The grain density (rock densi
ty on a porosity-free basis) of the pelites increases systematically a
s metamorphic grade increases. The mass loss and grain density increas
es are interpreted to have caused significant decreases in volume. Est
imates of average volume change for the garnet, staurolite, and kyanit
e zone pelites are -12 +/- 10 percent, -22 +/- 6 percent, and -28 +/-
6 percent, respectively (+/- 2sigma), relative to the chlorite and bio
tite zone rocks. The degree of mass transfer and volume change was var
iable within individual outcrops. The results of this study indicate t
hat significant, heretofore unrecognized changes in the composition an
d volume of aluminous pelite may occur during Barrovian style metamorp
hism.