Dh. Shapiro, EXAMINING THE CONTENT AND CONTEXT OF MEDITATION - A CHALLENGE FOR PSYCHOLOGY IN THE AREAS OF STRESS MANAGEMENT, PSYCHOTHERAPY, AND RELIGIONVALUES, Journal of humanistic psychology, 34(4), 1994, pp. 101-135
Studies have primarily examined meditation's effects as a self-regulat
ion strategy for stress management. Fewer studies have examined its ut
ility as a self-exploration strategy for enhancing psychological healt
h in psychotherapy and behavior change. And, few studies have examined
meditation's effect regarding its original religious purpose as a sel
f-liberation strategy to enhance spiritual growth and wisdom, and cult
ivate compassionate service. This article examines the reasons underly
ing this differential proportion of studies on each of the above varia
bles and details the merits and limitations of research that attempted
to remove the religious and philosophical context of meditation in or
der to focus on its content. The article then examines why it has been
necessary to reintroduce the context of meditation as a variable, whe
ther that context be stress management, psychotherapy, or a religious
perspective. Finally, based on the mentalist and cognitive revolution,
this article asks: ''Is God always a confounding variable in meditati
on research?''