Mg. Greene et al., OLDER PATIENT SATISFACTION WITH COMMUNICATION DURING AN INITIAL MEDICAL ENCOUNTER, Social science & medicine, 38(9), 1994, pp. 1279-1288
There has been extensive research on the factors associated with patie
nt satisfaction with communication during medical encounters, however,
little attention has been paid to satisfaction among subgroups of pat
ients, including the elderly. It is inappropriate to assume that all p
atients have the same physician-patient relationship needs, and thus,
they will all be satisfied with the same communication approaches duri
ng medical visits. In this study, we examine the interactional correla
tes of older patient satisfaction with an initial visit with a general
internist. A multidisciplinary team composed of social scientists and
physicians used the Multi-dimensional Interaction Analysis system to
code audiotapes. Patients and physicians completed post-visit satisfac
tion questionnaires. Older patient satisfaction was positively correla
ted with the following variables: physician questioning and supportive
ness on patient-raised topics; patient information-giving on patient-r
aised topics; the length of the visit; the physician's use of question
s worded in the negative; shared laughter between and the patient; and
physician satisfaction. These findings suggest that older patients pr
efer encounters in which: (1) there is physician supportiveness and sh
ared laughter; (2) they are questioned about and given an opportunity
to provide information on their own agenda items; and (3) physicians p
rovide some structure for the first meeting through their use of quest
ions worded in the negative. The authors caution that although this sa
mple of older patients appears to be satisfied with a communication st
yle usually considered characteristic of the traditional model of the
physician-patient relationship (i.e. a warm interpersonal style and ph
ysician-generated structure for the visit), older patients in other se
ttings and future cohorts of elderly patients may prefer other communi
cation approaches. It is also suggested that aspects of communication
which provide satisfaction to patients in first visit may be different
than aspects of communication associated with patient satisfaction in
follow-up visits.