M. Challacombe et J. Cioslowski, ACCURATE ELECTRON-DENSITIES FROM THE HILLER-SUCHER-FEINBERG IDENTITY APPLIED TO CONSTRAINED WAVE-FUNCTIONS, Molecular physics, 83(1), 1994, pp. 171-181
When applied to electronic wavefunctions calculated with Gaussian-type
basis functions, the Hiller-Sucher- Feinberg (HSF) identity improves
the accuracy of the electron density at non-hydrogen nuclei by more th
an an order of magnitude, yielding approximate electron nuclear cusps.
However, the HSF electron densities at hydrogen nuclei bound to heavy
atoms are greatly overestimated. This phenomenon is associated with t
he asymptotic behaviour of the HSF density, which incorrectly decrease
s to a constant when the sum of Hellmann-Feynman forces acting on nucl
ei is finite. A method for constraining variational wavefunctions to y
ield vanishing Hellmann-Feynman forces is described. Hartree-Fock calc
ulations of the constrained HSF (CHSF) electron densities with the 6-3
1G, 6-31G*, and 6-311++G** basis sets are reported at the nuclei of v
arious diatomic molecules, and are compared with their corresponding c
onventional, HSF, and Hartree-Fock limit values. These calculations sh
ow that differences between HSF and CHSF densities are minor at non-hy
drogen nuclei. Importantly, the calculated HF/6-311 + +G* CHSF densit
ies are on average three times more accurate than the conventional den
sities at hydrogen nuclei.