This paper gives a comparison of the approach of the US courts and of
the Solicitor's Disciplinary Tribunal in England to disciplinary proce
edings concerning lawyers suffering from alcohol dependence and/or dep
ression. A richer case law in the USA indicates a more sophisticated a
pproach, higher standards as to evidence and better support systems fo
r lawyers in recovery. Useful lessons could be learned from the Americ
an experience and the experience of doctors and dentists by English la
wyers.