S. Nava et al., SURVIVAL AND PREDICTION OF SUCCESSFUL VENTILATOR WEANING IN COPD PATIENTS REQUIRING MECHANICAL VENTILATION FOR MORE THAN 21 DAYS, The European respiratory journal, 7(9), 1994, pp. 1645-1652
We studied survival and failure or success of weaning from mechanical
ventilation (MV) in 42 consecutive chronic obstructive pulmonary disea
se (COPD) patients requiring prolonged MV (more than 21 days) after an
episode of acute respiratory failure requiring admission to our Inter
mediate Intensive Care Unit (IICU). Parameters including arterial bloo
d gases, pulmonary function tests, respiratory muscle force, neuromusc
ular drive, and nutritional status were recorded during a phase of cli
nical stability, in order to identify the features related to survival
and weaning. All the patients were submitted to a comprehensive rehab
ilitation programme. Successful weaning from MV was defined as complet
e respiratory autonomy for at least 48 h. Twenty three patients were s
uccessfully weaned from MV after an average period of 44 days (Group A
), requiring no further MV during their stay in hospital, whilst the r
emaining 19 patients were not able to be disconnected from the ventila
tor (Group B). The discriminant analysis showed that weaning from MV w
as significantly associated with arterial carbon dioxide tension (Paco
(2)), neuromuscular drive (P-0.1), maximal inspiratory pressure (MIP),
arterial oxygen tension (Pao(2)), the ratio of respiratory frequency
to tidal volume (f/VT) and the serum protein level. Other pulmonary fu
nction tests (forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV(1))), FEV(1)
/forced vital capacity (FVC), anthropometric data, nutritional status,
number of pulmonary exacerbations during MV and evidence of cor pulmo
nale, were similar in the two groups. The discriminant equation consid
ering Paco(2) and MIP could separate the two groups with an accuracy o
f 84%. The overall survival at 2 yrs was 40%; in Group B it was signif
icantly lower than in Group A (22 vs 68%). Most of the deaths occurred
within the first 120 days after intubation. None of the parameters co
nsidered could significantly predict the survival rate. We conclude th
at more than half of COPD patients requiring prolonged MV (more than 2
1 days) could be successfully weaned. A simple equation including Paco
(2) and MIP could correctly identify the weaning success or failure in
about 84% of patients. The survival rate at 2 yrs is poor in those wh
o could not be weaned, but is not associated with any of the indices c
onsidered.