QUANTITATIVE IMMUNOCYTOCHEMICAL ASSAYS OF P-GLYCOPROTEIN IN BREAST CARCINOMAS - CORRELATION TO MESSENGER-RNA EXPRESSION AND TO IMMUNOHISTOCHEMICAL PROGNOSTIC INDICATORS
C. Charpin et al., QUANTITATIVE IMMUNOCYTOCHEMICAL ASSAYS OF P-GLYCOPROTEIN IN BREAST CARCINOMAS - CORRELATION TO MESSENGER-RNA EXPRESSION AND TO IMMUNOHISTOCHEMICAL PROGNOSTIC INDICATORS, Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 86(20), 1994, pp. 1539-1545
Background: Chemotherapy failure that is due to cellular drug resistan
ce remains a major problem in most cancer patients. One type of drug r
esistance that has been characterized is the multidrug resistance phen
omenon, which demonstrates a reduced ability of cancer cells to accumu
late drugs as a result of the effects of an energy-dependent unidirect
ional drug efflux pump with a broad substrate specificity. This drug p
ump is composed of a 170-kd transmembrane glycoprotein referred to as
the P-glycoprotein (P-gp) that uses energy in the form of adenosine tr
iphosphate to transport drugs through a channel formed by transmembran
e segments. Purpose: Our purpose was fo detect the levels of P-gp expr
ession in frozen untreated breast carcinomas by immunocytochemical ass
ays and to correlate these levels to current prognostic indicators and
, in a few cases, to MDR1 (also known as PGY1) mRNA expression by poly
merase chain reaction (PCR). Methods: The immunocytochemical expressio
n of the multidrug resistance gene, P-gp, was investigated using a spe
cific monoclonal antibody (JSB1) against P-gp in 5-mu m frozen sequent
ial sections of breast carcinomas obtained from 213 patients. Microsco
pic images of immunostained preparations were evaluated by image analy
sis and were compared with MDR1 transcription (mRNA) assessed by PCR i
n 16 patients. Quantitative P-gp immunocytochemical assays were correl
ated to histoprognostic factors and immunocytochemical indicators. Res
ults: Among the 213 breast carcinomas tested, 113 (53%) mere P-gp posi
tive, but in 28% of the tumors, the immunostained surface accounted fo
r less than 5% of the total area stained. Quantitative immunocytochemi
stry reflecting the amount of intracellular P-gp antigen strongly corr
elated (r = 0.865; two-sided, P<.0001; Pearson's test) with the quanti
tative evaluation of the scanner analysis of mRNA transcripts. The P-g
p expression was significantly (two-sided, P<.001) correlated with p53
expression in tumors, to cathepsin D and Ki67 (two-sided, P<.01) immu
noreactivity, and to a lesser extent, the detection of estrogen recept
or antigenic sites (two-sided, P =.019). P-gp expression was found to
be independent of expressions of progesterone receptor and pS2, pHER-2
/neu, and CD31 in tumors and from patient age, tumor size, histologic
types, grades and Nottingham prognostic index, and nodal status. Concl
usions: The quantitative immunocytochemical assays of P-gp are correla
ted to PCR analysis of MDR1 expression, and such correlations can be u
seful in evaluating potential multidrug resistance in breast cancer. H
owever, the clinical significance of P-gp immunodetections remains to
be further determined.