G. Berci et L. Morgenstern, LAPAROSCOPIC MANAGEMENT OF COMMON BILE-DUCT STONES - A MULTIINSTITUTIONAL SAGES STUDY, Surgical endoscopy, 8(10), 1994, pp. 1168-1175
Laparoscopic common bile duct exploration (CBDE) was the subject of a
multi-institutional study on 226 patients from 19 major hospital cente
rs. Female patients predominated (2.3: 1); the average age was 54; 75%
of cases were chronic, and the remainder were acute. Although 97% had
preoperative ultrasonograms, only 12% showed a stone in the dilated c
ommon bile duct. The alkaline phosphatase was elevated in 41% and the
serum bilirubin in 28% of cases. Preoperative endoscopic retrograde ch
olangiography with sphincterotomy (ERC-ES) was performed in 8.5%; ther
e was a successful stone extraction in less than half the cases. Chola
ngiography was performed in 99.5%, and in 94% of those cases, stones w
ere found. In 83% of cases, stones were removed through the transcysti
c approach, and in 17% removal was throughout the CBD. In the majority
of cases, the choledochoscope and wire basket (34%), irrigation (33%)
, or a combination of both was employed. In the transcystic group, 5%
were converted to open procedures due to technical difficulty, as cont
rasted with the trans-CBD route, where the conversion rate was 19%. Th
ere were two ductal injuries. Minor complications occurred in 5.7% wit
hin 24 h; there was one death (0.4%). Within 30 days, the morbidity ra
te was 7% and there were no deaths. Retained stones were discovered in
2.6% of cases. Laparoscopic CBDE is a feasible approach for CBD stone
s which permits a definitive procedure in one stage, without pre- or p
ostoperative ES. It is a skill which should be mastered by the biliary
surgeon. Further improvement in instrumentation and technique should
make the laparoscopic approach not only comparable but preferable to t
he standard open choledocholithotomy.